Monday, January 30, 2012

Rape victims' champion: 'Let us not forget that those falsely accused are also real victims'

Rikki Klieman is a  former Massachusetts sex crimes prosecutor, a member of the board of the Rape Treatment Center in Los Angeles, and a fierce champion of rape victims. Unlike so many shrill, extremist voices in the blogosphere, Ms. Klieman understands the balance we always talk about here -- about the need to punish rapists while insuring the innocent aren't punished with them.  Serious voices on rape appreciate the balance -- see here

You need to read the entire article here, but she ends with this:

"Let us not forget that those falsely accused are also real victims. They are forever painted by some with a label of 'rapist,' whether the case is dismissed or they are acquitted. I am still haunted by the memory of defending a therapist accused of date rape at a party years ago. There is no question in my mind that the act was consensual. She pursued him vigorously and he rebuffed her attention before she made her complaint. What other course might the case have taken had he sent her flowers or taken her on another date? The specter of the publicity in his professional life and the stress surrounding the progress of the case contributed to his suicide. He is not alone in taking such a desperate step.

"All of society loses when there is a false accusation. Somehow we must encourage real victims to feel safe to report rape knowing that police and prosecutors will have the courage to turn away those who bear false witness. Society itself can become the victim. We don’t want guilty people on the street who will offend again. We want to safeguard the most vulnerable among us. We want to champion those violated. We want to protect the falsely accused."

3 comments:

slwerner said...

Okay, I couldn't let this one go without comment.

(from the linked article comments) siri - "The accused is a "victim" really? How far will we go to prove that women are
2nd class citizens, just objects. NO means NO even if the woman is naked in time square. "


So, if men are also victims that somehow diminishes women? If, in a given case, based on the evidence uncovered, a man is believed, and a woman is disbelieved, this denigrates woman to 2nd class status?

Really!?!?

What would this siri entity like to see happen? Should the entirety of the criminal justice system be suspended for any and all allegations of rape, and any man accused (or who just fits the description well enough) be presumed guilty and thrown immediately into prison - no investigation, no trial, no chance to defend himself against the charges?

Should all men simply be assumed guilty, and the possibility of their having been victims completely ignored lest some women of extremely low intellectual capacity be left feeling that unless men are just routinely convicted as soon as they are accused, then women are being relegated to 2nd-class status?

Archivist said...

Great comment, sl. It is almost comical to read a comment by one of these "women don't lie" banshees. We are seeing fewer and fewer of these with each passing year as our message starts to drip into the public discourse, and comments like that are now jarring to read.

Let's just leave it at this: the person who made the comment is an idiot. Period.

Mjolinir said...

This article may be of interest [The author's job is somewhat similar to that of a US District Attorney]
\\
Alison Saunders, the head of the Crown Prosecution Service in London, claimed jurors’ preconceptions about women affected the way they considered evidence.
Ms Saunders said stereotypes, particularly around women who have been drinking, or those who have been sexually assaulted by their partner, needed to be challenged.
She also expressed concern about the way women were portrayed in the media saying many were “demonised” unfairly.
\\
Ms Saunders said prosecutors and detectives involved in rape cases were now better equipped in understanding the difficulties victims faced. She pointed out that judges could give advice and directions during a trial, but that often this came too late to make jurors think twice.
\\
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/9048372/Rape-victims-fear-being-demonised-says-CPS-chief.html