Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Breaking News: Heidi Jones Pleads Guilty to False Reporting

This is an update on this post and this one about Heidi Jones, the New York TV meteorologist who claimed she was the victim of an attempted rape last September 24 at the hands of an unnamed Hispanic man. The incident supposedly occurred while she jogged in Central Park. She also claimed that the same man showed up near her Manhattan apartment almost two months later, and allegedly told her: “I know you went to the police.” 

None of it happened. Ms. Jones today pled guilty to two misdemeanor counts of falsely reporting an incident. The judge says she will be sentenced to three years' probation and 350 hours of community service.

Mrs. Jones does not seem to have acted with malice, but it is well to note that even rape lies that don't intend to target an individual sometimes do -- that's because, once unleashed, a rape lie is impossible to control short of recanting. In this case, "she provided a detailed description – including the alleged attacker's race, height and clothing," see here, and if the police had found someone without an alibi who matched that description, as has happened in other cases, the consequences could have been very damaging.

Jones' claim was yst another unfortunate high profile rape lie that does no favor to actual rape victims. Rape victims need to be assured by counselors that Ms. Jones was obviously a troubled  individual; her lie has nothing to do with an actual rape, and there is no reason to allow Ms. Jones' lie to interfere with reporting rape.

It is also unfortunate that Jones targeted an imaginary Hispanic rapist, a troubling racist ploy likely intended to enhance the plausibility and scariness of the lie.  Her claim did no favors for the Hispanic community. See our post When Rape Lies Tap Into Racial Stereotypes.

Ms. Jones seems more troubled than evil. We hope she gets the help she needs, for her sake and, especially, for the sake of others she might someday hurt.  Too bad Crystal Mangum didn't get the help she needed before it was too late.

Here is the news report:

NYC TV meteorologist admits false attack claims

NEW YORK — A TV meteorologist has admitted making up claims of being attacked twice in New York City, sparking an extensive police investigation.
 
Heidi Jones pleaded guilty Wednesday to two misdemeanor counts of falsely reporting an incident. The judge says she will be sentenced to three years' probation and 350 hours of community service. That's the time prosecutors say police spent looking into her phony claims.

Jones told police Dec. 1 a man had attacked her in Central Park last September and again outside her apartment in November.

Jones has been suspended from her job at New York's local ABC station.

She previously worked in cities including Albany, N.Y., and Houston.

She also has filled in on ABC's "Good Morning America."

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/44519867/ns/us_news/

17 comments:

DoesntHaveAnAccount said...

I don't understand why she hasn't been fired by ABC, only suspended. News relies on the truth and if she can blatantly lie about sexual assault then lying about pretty much anything else should be easy.

Anonymous said...

Don't tell me that feminism doesn't control the legal system and the media.

Did anyone really think she would get any jail time?

Extremely Disgruntled said...

It's SOMETHING in the right direction. We just have to make it more of a "issue" in the public's eye, so the public will punish it harder. Remember, any "Public Opinion Issues" = "Guilty" as of late. See also the Casey Anthony coverage by Certain Reporters, etc. Maybe we can even name a law after Heidi Jones?

ScareCrow said...

I am surprised that she got a sentence at all.

Her sentence should be the same as what a rapist would get.

Anonymous said...

Because gender-feminist quack-ademics have told American law enforcement to "manufacture the misinformation" that less than 2% of rape accusations are false, it has led law enforcement to not charge false rape accusers, in order to manufacture the 2%.

Archivist said...

Extremely: Yeah, Heidi's Law, which would punish the rape liar the same as the alleged rapist would have received. I like it.

ScareCrow: I agree, on both counts.

Anonymous said...

We have a little mens rights dictionary that is being crafted as we speak.
Jane crow laws: (n), modern gender-feminist manipulations of "campus courts" that effectively remove a guy falsely accused of rape from equitably defending himself.

grand negus said...

she should be charged as if she herself has committed a rape.she must have known nothing happens to blond/blue eyed girls when they say a hispanic raped her.Now, if she were black or brown, the christian right would be screaming for blood.

grand negus said...

charge her just like she committed rape.some innocent hispanic would be dragged kicking and screaming into jail just bcos sweet and pure GOLDILOCKS said so.if they had found a suspect, she would never come forward.Maybe in her deathbed she might fess up.

Arod99k said...

I would love to see this woman Perp-Walked in hand cuffs, across the front page of ABC and CNN.

We should register her at Registerher.com

Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...
Don't tell me that feminism doesn't control the legal system and the media.

Did anyone really think she would get any jail time?

Sep 14, 2011 4:49:00 PM

I didn't think she would get any jail time.

proudmale877 said...

Actually it sounds like several innocent guys were rounded up on account of Heidi's lie.

http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/manhattan/guilty_the_girl_who_cried_rape_T63iVq26oIDdSc6ZewdY8I

"Cops pored over surveillance video from Central Park and around Jones’ building, where she said the same attacker -- a 40-something Hispanic man, 5-foot-7 to 5-foot-10 -- stalked her last Nov. 21.
Officers even stopped a man fitting her phony profile outside her pad, took his photo and put him in a picture lineup for Jones."

Anonymous said...

"Her sentence should be the same as what a rapist would get."
_______________________

No, her sentence should not be that of a rapist. There is no physical comparison. 350 hours of community service sounds about right. She should have gotten minimal jail time as well.

I, too, like the ring of Heidi's Law for those guilty of false accusations. Such a law could be a huge turning point for your crusade!

Archivist said...

Thanks, Anon at 6:49. That changes things. A false rape claim can be more awful than a physical assault, even without a conviction. We advocate a sliding scale for punishments, and I do think a custodial sentence is warranted when an innocent person is targeted.

I once was physically assaulted as a teenager and would prefer that over what happened to the man in Lauren Weedman's story: http://www.falserape.net/rapestory.pdf -- are you familiar with it?

Lauren had no intention of hurting anyone with her admittedly stupid rape lie. But then the cops found someone who, they claimed, matched her imaginary description. How do you quanitify the harm to the man she describes in her account? Do you dismiss it just because he wasn't convicted? Here's what happened when she attended the police line-up -- trigger warning -- this is rather disturbing:

"They lined up a row of men, but I was sure of who they suspected; he was the only one who was told where to stand. . . . I felt sick. Thanks to me this man knew how it felt to be treated like a violent criminal.

"As they pushed the guy around to show me what he looked like in profile, I could barely breathe. I wanted it to be over as quickly as possible--for everyone. I said, 'No, that's not him. None of them.'

"The detective standing at my side kept telling me, 'Just wait. Let's bring him up so you can get a look at him.'

"When they finally pushed him up to the glass, he was crying. He looked terrified.

"'No,' I said sharply. 'That's not him. I'm 100% sure. . . .

"I went into the bathroom and sobbed."

Beat me up but please don't put me through that.

Heidi Jones should find that man and personally apologize to him.

concerned citizen said...

I agree; Hedi's law it is. From here on out, we need to refine what "Heidi's law" should look like.

Anonymous said...

///Now, if she were black or brown, the christian right would be screaming for blood.////



Exactly what black or brown woman has this happened to? Certainly not Crystal mangum or Nafissatou Diallo.

The only "racism" going on here is the presumption that blacks or browns are treated worse in the just us system, when in fact, black and brown women enjoy as much, if not MORE, encouragement in their false accusation by BOTH genders and ALL races.

It's MALES that can't get their act together and stop the in house grudges to unite against a common enemy: false accusations and unConstitutional laws designed to convict innocent men.

There is an effort to ressurect "women don't lie" lynch laws - NOT "white women don't lie" lynch laws.

If you have a penis you ARE the enemy.

Anonymous said...

I wasn't talking about the women.All women get a free ride.I AM TALKING ABOUT MEN OF COLOR WHICH ARE ALLWAYS THE VICTIM/SCAPEGOAT/WHIPPING BOYS.you want an amen, then go to opra and helen.